Vael Creative The AI Concierge Index
← The table

How the score works

If a venue disputes its score, this page is the answer. Everything below is published because everything below is checkable.

1. What we measure

For each reading we ask three AI assistants (ChatGPT, Gemini and Claude) a fixed set of 50 questions a real traveler, wedding planner or event organizer would ask about the market. Every question is asked three times per engine, in fresh sessions through each provider's API with live web search turned on. The model versions are listed with every reading. The API answers can differ from the consumer apps, which add their own settings and personalization. That is 450 answers per reading: 50 queries × 3 engines × 3 runs.

Each live market has had its first reading, and later readings repeat on a schedule that this page will announce. A market marked first reading pending has its venue list and questions published, and it gets scores once its first reading runs.

For every answer we record the model and version, the date and time, the full text, every venue named, the order venues appear in, any links or citations shown, and the language used about each venue.

2. What counts as a mention

3. The four components

Presence: 40 points. The share of the 450 answers in a reading in which the venue appears at all. It is a plain count that anyone can verify against the archived transcripts.

Presence = (runs where venue is mentioned / 450) × 40

Prominence: 25 points. How the venue appears when it does. Each mention is graded:

GradeConditionValue
LeadFirst venue named, or the single recommendation1.00
FeaturedNamed with descriptive language: why it's good, who it's for0.75
ListedNamed in a list with no description0.40
Prominence = (average grade across all mentions) × 25

Citation: 20 points. The share of mentions with a link to the venue's own website. Links to OTAs, review sites or listicles do not count, because a booking through a middleman pays commission. Citation is measured only on engines that showed links in that reading, and each reading lists them. In the first reading, Claude's answers carried no links, so citation there comes from ChatGPT and Gemini.

Citation = (mentions linking to the venue's own domain / mentions on engines that showed links) × 20

Stability: 15 points. Whether the recommendation survives repetition. For each of the 150 query-engine pairs, we ask three times. Stability is the average, across pairs where the venue appears at least once, of runs-with-mention divided by 3. A venue that flickers in and out scores low; a lucky single answer is not a reputation.

Stability = average over eligible pairs of (runs with mention / 3) × 15
AI Concierge Score = Presence + Prominence + Citation + Stability

4. Limits

5. Commercial independence

Scores cannot be bought, and no commercial relationship with Vael Creative affects any score. Clients and non-clients are scored by the same runs from the same transcripts.

Properties marked † on the table and on their score pages are Vael Creative clients. Scores are computed from the published query set before any client work begins, and no client input affects scoring. A script applies the mark from the venue seed file, so nobody can add or remove it for a single reading.

6. Disputes

Any venue can request a re-score. We re-run the full battery for the disputed reading and publish the result, whatever it shows. Raw transcripts behind every published score are available on request: brian@vaelcreative.com.